Back to Case Studies

    One Tender, Five Convoys

    A retrospective operational reconstruction of a 2016 gasoil discharge by barge convoy

    Hugo Federico Hernández Varela
    Lead Advisor
    Hugo Federico Hernández Varela

    Maritime Operations & Commercial Contracts Consultant

    View Profile
    Key Outcome

    A structured operational record separating supported events from entries exposed to factual or documentary challenge.

    Operational Reconstruction / Maritime Analysis

    Hugo Federico Hernández Varela

    Maritime Operations & Commercial Contracts Consultant

    SCOPE AND LIMITS

    The vessel, receivers and barge operators are not identified. All times are local. The charter party, original bills of lading, laboratory reports and correspondence were not among the records reviewed. Bill-of-lading quantity figures were available within the quantity records. The reconstruction therefore identifies contractual questions but does not answer them. It expresses no view on laytime, demurrage entitlement or liability.

    KEY FIGURES

    • Cargo: gasoil 10 ppm, 31,024 MT per bill-of-lading quantity figures
    • Discharge: four bills of lading, five barge convoys, three receiving interests
    • Duration: Notice of Readiness tendered at 0412 on 2 March; discharge ran from 2236 on 2 March to 2348 on 5 March; the vessel sailed early on 6 March
    • Notice of Readiness: one tender, evidenced by five separate NOR forms
    • Letters of protest: seven (three for waiting time, four for discharge rate)
    • Protested waiting time: 23 hours 34 minutes across five entries

    THE OPERATION

    A product tanker anchored at a South American river lightering area and tendered Notice of Readiness at 0412 on 2 March. The 31,024 MT cargo was discharged into barge convoys in sequence. Four bills of lading were discharged across five convoys. The first parcel (BL 4A) was split between convoys 1 and 2 because convoy 1 stopped on barge draft with the parcel part-discharged.

    • Convoy 1: 4 barges, BL 4A (part), receiver A. All fast 2024 on 2 March. Hoses connected and NOR received 2200. Discharge started 2236 per both SOFs (2250 per the pumping log). Stopped 0448 on 3 March.
    • Convoy 2: 5 barges, BL 4A (completion), receiver A. All fast 1942 on 3 March. Hoses connected and NOR received 2042. Discharge started 2100. Completed 0812 on 4 March.
    • Convoy 3: 2 barges, BL 4B, receiver A. All fast 1112 on 4 March. Hoses connected and NOR received 1200. Discharge started 1230. Completed 1642.
    • Convoy 4: 5 barges, BL 3, receiver B. All fast 2036 on 4 March. Hoses connected and NOR received 0018 on 5 March. Discharge started 0118. Completed 1612.
    • Convoy 5: 1 barge, BL 2, receiver C. All fast 1942 on 5 March. Hoses connected 2000 per the agent SOF, 2024 per the vessel SOF and the NOR form. Discharge started 2024 per the agent SOF, 2030 per the vessel SOF. Completed 2348.

    Tanks were certified empty at 0024 on 6 March. Documents and outward clearance were completed at 0130.

    AREA 1: ONE TENDER, FIVE NOR FORMS

    The master tendered Notice of Readiness once, at 0412 on 2 March. The file contains five NOR forms, addressed to the barge sets of each convoy and dated 2, 3, 4, 4 and 5 March. Each states that the vessel arrived and tendered at 0412 on 2 March. The question is therefore not whether one NOR was used, but what each later-dated form evidences and what contractual significance it may have for each parcel and receiver.

    The timing of the tender is a separate issue. The agent SOF records anchoring at 0430, free pratique at 0500, the boarding party at 0700 and inward clearance at 0730. The vessel SOF records the vessel anchored at 0412 and agent, coast guard and surveyors on board at 0430. Whether tender before anchoring, free pratique or clearance matters depends on the charter party, which was not reviewed.

    AREA 2: RECEIPT IS NOT ACCEPTANCE

    Both SOFs record "N.O.R. accepted" at each convoy. The documents show something different.

    • Convoys 1 to 3: the pre-printed word "accepted" is struck through on the forms and the stamp reads "Solo recibido / only received / without prejudice", signed on behalf of receiver A.
    • Convoys 4 and 5: the forms show a date and time of acceptance with no visible qualifier in the copies reviewed.

    Elapsed time from the 0412 tender to receipt: convoy 1, 17h48m; convoy 2, 40h30m; convoy 3, 55h48m; convoy 4, 68h06m; convoy 5, 88h12m. The record does not show one acceptance event. It shows five receipts at five different times, three of them expressly qualified.

    AREA 3: WAITING TIME

    Three delay protests contain five entries, totalling 23 hours 34 minutes. Each was tested against both SOFs.

    • Entry 1, 2 March 1100-2000 (9h00). Cargo calculations were completed at 1100, but samples were not passed by the laboratory until 1840. The first 7h40m falls before laboratory clearance and is exposed to challenge. The remaining 1h20m is consistent with the records.
    • Entry 2, 3 March 0818-1930 (11h12m). The agent SOF records the vessel idle awaiting the second convoy from 0818 to 1848, but also logs the convoy approaching at 1648. The protest runs 42 minutes beyond the end of the agent's idle entry.
    • Entry 3, 4 March 1030-1124 (0h54). Both SOFs record barges alongside at 1112, so the protest runs 12 minutes beyond that point.
    • Entry 4, 4 March 1920-2036 (1h16). Consistent with both SOFs.
    • Entry 5, 5 March 1830-1942 (1h12). Consistent with both SOFs.

    In total, 8h34m is exposed to challenge on timing (7h40m + 42m + 12m). The remaining 15h00m is consistent with the contemporaneous records, subject to the internal inconsistency noted for entry 2.

    Notification was not contemporaneous. The protest covering entries 1 to 3 was received at about 1910 on 4 March, roughly 47 hours after entry 1 ended. The protest for entry 4 was received at 1805 on 5 March. The protest for entry 5 was received at 0145 on 6 March.

    AREA 4: DISCHARGE RATE

    Four rate protests record the vessel's six 12-inch manifolds against two 6-inch barge connections for convoys 1 to 4, and one 12-inch manifold against one 6-inch connection for convoy 5. Manifold pressure was held at 7.0 bar. Average rates stated on the protests were:

    • BL 4A: 1017.80 m³/h
    • BL 4B: 1195.13 m³/h
    • BL 3: 1097.02 m³/h
    • BL 2: 459.39 m³/h

    The figures for BL 4B, BL 3 and BL 2 reproduce from the pumping logs and ullage reports. The BL 4A figure, which spans two convoys, could not be reproduced from the recorded times.

    The pumping logs record an agreed maximum pumping rate of 1000 m³/h, which the vessel exceeded on three parcels. The same logs record the shore maximum rate inconsistently (1500, 1300, 1600, 1400 and 600 m³/h), while the protests state a terminal request of 1400. The record supports a receiving-side operational limitation associated with the barge connection arrangement, but it does not quantify the capacity of those connections. The rate protest for BL 3 is dated 4 March, although that parcel was discharged on 5 March and the protest was received at 1805 on 5 March.

    AREA 5: INTERNAL CONSISTENCY OF THE RECORD

    • Vessel SOF: the bill-of-lading references are wrong at 1612 (shown as 04B, should be 03), at 2030 (shown as 03, should be 02) and at 2348 (shown as 04B, should be 02), all on 5 March.
    • Convoy 5 timing: the agent SOF records hoses connected and NOR accepted at 2000; the NOR form is stamped 2024 and the vessel SOF records hoses connected at 2024.
    • Agent SOF: idle until 1848 on 3 March but convoy approaching at 1648.
    • Convoy 1 start: 2236 in both SOFs, 2250 in the pumping log.
    • Ullage report "after B/L 4B" is dated 3 March, but BL 4B was completed on 4 March.
    • Arrival sequence: the vessel SOF has the vessel anchored at 0412 and authorities on board at 0430; the agent SOF has anchoring at 0430 and the boarding party at 0700.

    These inconsistencies appear across several vessel and agent records. None of them alone determines a commercial position, but together they limit how far any single document can be relied on.

    AREA 6: QUANTITIES

    Total cargo on board before discharge: bill-of-lading quantity 31,024.062 MT; vessel 30,975.753 MT; independent surveyor 30,974.519 MT. The vessel and surveyor figures are within 1.3 MT of each other and about 0.16% below the bill-of-lading quantity.

    By parcel (bill-of-lading / vessel / surveyor, in MT):

    • BL 4A: 13,732.641 / 13,708.174 / 13,706.941
    • BL 4B: 4,136.326 / 4,128.910 / 4,128.903
    • BL 3: 11,912.645 / 11,893.932 / 11,893.938
    • BL 2 (quantity remaining after BL 3): 1,242.450 / 1,244.736 / 1,244.737

    The vessel experience factor applied was 0.99778. The three earlier parcels show vessel figures below the bill-of-lading figures; the final parcel shows the vessel figure above it because it is the quantity left on board after BL 3.

    THE RECONSTRUCTION

    Before

    • One ambiguous timeline for five operations.
    • A blanket 23.5-hour delay claim.
    • An unexplained reduction in discharge rate.
    • Documentary errors left unexplained.
    • A position easily challenged.

    After

    • Five separate operational timelines, one per convoy.
    • Delay windows tested individually against both SOFs.
    • Receipt and acceptance of each NOR form distinguished.
    • The rate limitation tied to the barge connection arrangement, with the limits of the evidence stated.
    • Documentary inconsistencies identified so they can be explained rather than discovered by the other side.
    • A record that can be used to test any contractual or demurrage position.

    RECORDS REVIEWED

    Agent statement of facts; vessel statement of facts; five Notices of Readiness with receipt annotations; seven letters of protest; five pumping logs; five ullage reports; tank inspection certificate; vessel experience factor sheet; bill-of-lading, vessel and surveyor quantity figures.

    Ready to Achieve Similar Results?

    Connect with our advisors to discuss how we can help transform your operations.